I have had more questions about this strip than any other I think I have ever done. My more literal-minded friends and readers just don’t get it … and it apparently can’t be explained.
I tried instigating this debate back when I was on FB and the only people who would respond would come up with a third name. Apparently, none of them understood the concept of a binary choice.
In case you’re wondering, what Monty is saying there in the third panel has nothing to do with the conversation. It is strictly about Pete’s archery skills.